He Said / She Said (Episode 1)

Prose vs. Pace

Welcome to He Said / She Said, a new Just Reading Nook column where two writers take opposite sides of one question about books and the craft of writing. There’s no referee and no agreement required. You get both arguments, and you decide.

This round starts from common ground: story is king. Without a plot, nothing else matters. But once the story is in place, what takes second place in a great novel? She says pacing, the momentum that keeps the pages turning. He says prose, the language that makes you feel every one of those pages.

Let the debate begin.


Graphic featuring a woman in sunglasses with a speech bubble reading “SHE SAID” and the quote “Story is always king. But pace is what keeps readers turning the page.”

The Case for Pace

Story is always king. But pace is what keeps readers turning the page.

Story is the non-negotiable first priority. Without a clear through-line of desire, conflict, and consequence, nothing matters. There’s nothing for the reader to care about.

A book can survive clumsy sentences and still grip a reader, but it cannot survive a reader who feels nothing.

So story dominates. Now our Nook debate begins: does prose or pacing take the next place?

The case for prose is straightforward and appealing. Words are our jam. Language is the medium of storytelling. Distinctive voices, precise imagery, and rhythmic sentences create atmosphere, deepen emotion, and leave lines that stay with the reader long after the plot fades.

Sometimes, the pleasure of the writer’s control of the sentence makes the reading experience.

The case for pacing is less glamorous but more decisive for most readers.

Pacing is the control of momentum: when information is revealed, when pressure increases, when the reader slows to breathe. It is the difference between a story that is technically complete and a story that is compulsively readable.

A reader will race past uneven sentences or a flat patch of description if the next page keeps promising answers, complications, or emotional stakes.

The reverse is rarely true. Beautiful prose can stall, circle, or withhold too long without plot purpose. When that happens, readers disengage, no matter how elegant the language. Or maybe precisely because of the beauty.

Pacing is also the practical mechanism that opens up the plot and creates immersion. Suddenly, a story isn’t a lovely outline. It’s pounding tension or a sweet, slow dance.

Pace determines tension. Pace weaves the story’s path, building and releasing stress. Does the slow unfolding slip a clue past the reader, dropping it like a breadcrumb, or does it slam you face-first into the fray?

The relationship between character and pace is where this priority becomes clearest. Character is not separate from pacing; it is one of its primary drivers. What a character wants, what they fear, how quickly they decide, and how long they hesitate all dictate the tempo of individual scenes and of the larger story. An impulsive protagonist speeds up investigation or confrontation. A methodical or avoidant one stretches certain sequences, creating different kinds of tension. The reader feels the character’s personality through the speed and rhythm of their choices as much as through dialogue or interiority.

At the same time, pacing reveals and tests character. Compressed time under pressure strips away performance and shows instinctive reaction. Stretched time exposes obsession, doubt, or resilience.

In my crime stories, this interplay is especially potent. The detective’s particular way of thinking or feeling shapes how quickly clues are pursued, how long red herrings are entertained, and when the emotional cost of the case becomes unbearable. The pace is not imposed on the character; it emerges from the character’s relationship to the problem. When that relationship is clear, the story’s rhythm feels organic rather than managed.

Pacing is the connective tissue between plot and character. Plot supplies the destination and the obstacles. Character supplies the reasons for moving forward or holding back.

Prose supports this work by making the movement vivid and the pauses pretty, but it never substitutes for the movement itself.

The final test? A story can be rewritten for stronger sentences. But sentence-level editing can’t make up for the absence of real plot action.

Pace is the second-highest priority in a successful novel.


Graphic quote featuring JR Lariba’s portrait and the text, “The plot is the vehicle. Prose is why anyone gets in the car.”

HE SAID…

The Case for Prose: A Biased Opinion

The plot is the vehicle. Prose is why anyone gets in the car.

As the title implies, these are one writer’s opinions. Most of us can agree that story remains king. But that claim is often used to excuse thin writing. It’s true that no amount of beautiful sentences can save a story that has nothing to say. The reverse is also true, and less often admitted: a strong plot rendered in lifeless prose often fails to land the very emotional or intellectual payoff it was built to deliver. The events happen; the reader just doesn’t feel them. Prose is how the story actually reaches the reader.

Example:

Her eyes glistened. “I was young, we had plans, and the war ruined my chances of ever getting married.”

Her eyes, blue shot through with storm-cloud gray, glistened. “I was in the flower of my youth. We had plans. And now this war has left me a lingering bud on the vine, well past spring, with no hope for a visit from a bee.”

As the plot settles into the fabric of the page, it is prose that sets the stitch.

Prose is what makes a reader hold fast within the weave of the plot. Pace can usher readers through a scene or a chapter; prose is what makes them feel the texture of the moment. Prose is catharsis on every page. The staunch plot mechanics of a thriller can be forgotten in a week. A single well-crafted sentence can linger like a childhood memory. The plot may be the vehicle, but prose is the reason anyone gets in the car to begin with.

Pace is a tool; prose is a medium.

You can control pace with structure, sentence length, chapter breaks, and withheld information. Those are mechanical choices, strokes of the brush. Prose is the paint on the brush. It is what the story is made of: the voice, the immersion, the rhythm, the precision of the language. You can have great pacing with mediocre prose and still produce something unmemorable. The reverse is harder. Strong prose can carry uneven pacing; weak prose rarely survives even perfect pacing.

Memorable books are usually remembered for how they were written, not merely for what happened.

When people talk about the books that stayed with them, they rarely lead with “the pacing was excellent.” They talk about a voice, a way of seeing, a particular quality of language. Pace gets them to the end. Prose is usually why they cared.

Patience is earned, and forgiveness lives in the sentence.

Readers will tolerate digressions, slower sections, even occasional structural looseness when the voice is precise enough to turn the plot’s pressures into something felt at the sentence level rather than merely described. They are far less forgiving of flat, purely functional language, no matter how efficiently the plot moves. Prose gives you room to express style. Pace alone does not.

Outside, the church bells rang, calling the village to evening prayer. Liesl stepped into the dusk, the hills glowing emerald as they had when Hans sang for her. She would go to Pozières, to the Somme’s scarred earth, and demand answers from the stones. If Hans was there, in spirit or silence, she would hear him again. Of that much she was sure.


He Said / She Said is Just Reading Nook’s editorial column, where two writers take opposite sides of one question about books and the craft of writing. Each round, Collings MacCrae and J.R. Larriba pick a topic, take a side, and make their case.

Collings brings an author’s eye from inside the story, shaped by years of building tension and character in her crime fiction. J.R. reads like a reviewer, judging what lands on the page and what stays with a reader long after the last chapter. They don’t always disagree. When they do, they don’t hold back.

There’s no referee and no final verdict. You read both sides, and you decide.


Promotional image encouraging support for indie books and authors through Ko-fi donations, featuring a coffee cup graphic.

Leave a Reply